Broad Minds Encourage Broad Laughter

From The New York Times

January 15, 2010
By Chloe Veltman


It’s often been said that stand-up comedy is the most subjective art form. What’s side-splitting to one person is seditious to the next. Yet while the evolving dynamics of the Bay Area entertainment scene have broadened traditional definitions of what constitutes comedy, some of the audience still takes a narrow view of what’s funny and what isn’t.

With its kaleidoscopic lineup, the SF Sketchfest comedy festival, which opened on Thursday, should help audiences understand that there are many paths to humor beyond the traditional setup-and-punch-line-centric patter. As in previous years, the program, which features some 200 artists of local, national and international prominence, stretches standard notions to their limits.

The festival includes the embattled talk show host Conan O’Brien (Sunday); impressionists, among them James Adomian (next Sunday); improv and sketch comedy troupes, like the San Francisco-based Kasper Hauser (Tuesday and Jan. 30); absurdist comedians like Animosity Pierre (Tuesday and Thursday); sitcom actors like Scott Adsit of “30 Rock” (Jan. 30); solo theater artists, including Sara Benincasa (Saturday); and even a comedic jazz outfit, the Be-Bop Heroin Hour (Jan. 29 and 30). The festival perhaps went a step too far by inviting the singer-songwriter Aimee Mann, a musician whose plaintive ballads aren’t generally known for their laughter-inducing qualities.

Cultivating broad-mindedness toward these many forms of comedy is important. If audiences were open to a wider range of humorous performance, the demand for live comedy might grow. This would in turn lead to the rejuvenation of the once-lauded but sadly long-dormant San Francisco comedy scene, an arena that helped forge the careers of Phyllis Diller, Whoopi Goldberg and Robin Williams.

If audiences were willing to expand their definitions of comedy, they might relax and enjoy themselves rather than fret about how what they’re seeing onstage doesn’t conform to their expectations. Their heightened pleasure would doubtless have an overall positive effect on the community. In these dark times we can use all the opportunities for laughter we can get.

Personal taste notwithstanding, the negative reaction to a recent show I attended suggests that some Bay Area audience members may not have caught up with the changes that have taken place on the local comedy scene over the past decade or so. Or perhaps they chose to ignore the words “unconventional” and “groundbreaking” on the flier advertising the “Not Your Normal New Year’s Eve” comedy night at the Herbst Theater.

“The worst comedy lineup ever, full of nonsensical stream-of-consciousness musings and pathetic revelations,” wrote one reviewer on the ticketing site Another wrote, “We only stayed because our car was not ready to pick us up.” Contrastingly, I was thoroughly entertained.

The comedy scene has transformed partly because of the shuttering of several Bay Area comedy clubs in the 1990s and early 2000s, which forced artists to develop their work in other settings, like theaters and the Internet. While many local stand-up acts once focused on observational or autobiographical material, these days the scene is much more fragmented.

But there are still plenty of observational comics around. Of those who performed on New Year’s Eve, many of whom are also on the SF Sketchfest roster, Brent Weinbach most closely reflects that tradition.

But the other acts demonstrated radically different approaches. Will Franken, named “Best Alternative to Psychedelic Drugs” by The San Francisco Bay Guardian, offers an erudite brand of stream-of-consciousness comedy that encompasses bits like a poetry slam match between George Milton reciting the opening of “Paradise Lost” and a poetically challenged modern teenager doing some rap.

Mary Van Note’s humor hinges on misplaced sexual advances; this comedian is best known for her 10-part online video series about trying to woo Mayor Gavin Newsom.

Meanwhile, the surreal theatrics of We Are Nudes balance the over-the-top physicality of a former Cirque du Soleil performer, John Gilkey, against the awkward introversion of his comedic sidekicks, Donny Divanian and Alec Jones-Trujillo. The group’s act reaches its zenith with a protracted tirade from a supposed audience member about the performers’ lack of comedic skill.

Of course, the many people in the Herbst audience who responded unfavorably to the entertainment may simply not share my sense of humor. It may be that people need to get out and see a diverse range of live comedy. But the incentive to do so lies partly elsewhere.

While the SF Sketchfest helps to expand an understanding of the art of comedy, local promoters and clubs need to play a role year-round too. Bay Area audiences are by and large enlightened. If they shy away from the stranger side of comedy, it may also be because of the local industry’s narrow approach to programming and reluctance to book any act that steps beyond conventional realms. The Bay Area’s eclectic landscape should operate along the same lines as many an effective comic act: with a good punch line set up to defy expectations.

Back To Menu

319 thoughts on “Broad Minds Encourage Broad Laughter

  1. Pingback: Ashley Hale

  2. Pingback: vimax pills UK

  3. Pingback: wells dentist

  4. Pingback: frantzen

  5. Pingback: attraction

  6. Pingback: second post

  7. Pingback: youtube partner

  8. Pingback: Alla3 Cuffie4

  9. Pingback: target promotional code

  10. Pingback: parking

  11. Pingback: how to get your ex boyfriend back

  12. Pingback: how to get your ex girlfriend back

  13. Pingback: Mirena IUD Lawsuit

  14. Pingback: World Map

  15. Pingback: make money online

  16. Pingback: buy tumblr followers

  17. Pingback: ed supplements

  18. Pingback: Друзья друзей ЫбС

  19. Pingback: Anonymous

  20. Pingback: Slotomania Free Coins Iphone

  21. Pingback: karen millen uk online

  22. Pingback: ed cures

  23. Pingback: herbal remedies for ed

  24. Pingback: фильм Любовь в большом городе 3 2013 смотреть онлайн hd Окх

  25. Pingback: Adrian Morrison books

  26. Pingback: best ed treatment

  27. Pingback: Анал больно

  28. Pingback: Больной анал

  29. Pingback: Порно фото анал

  30. Pingback: Анал малолетки

  31. Pingback: erections

  32. Pingback: Tao Of Badass

  33. Pingback: computer repair san diego

  34. Pingback: safadas BH

  35. Pingback: lose belly fat in men

  36. Pingback: vacuum pump for ed

  37. Pingback: Payday Loans

  38. Pingback: Анал женщины

  39. Pingback: help with ed

  40. Pingback: herbal remedies for ed

  41. Pingback: Анал боль

  42. Pingback: Анал подборка

  43. Pingback: Член в анале

  44. Pingback: causes for ed

  45. Pingback: Бесплатное порно онлайн анал

  46. Pingback: holyghost mysecrect advantage

  47. Pingback: the woman prayed that Robbie Alekson would be safe

  48. Pingback: Жопа анал

  49. Pingback: best gas chlorinators for pools

  50. Pingback: pet sitter in naples

  51. Pingback: clash of clans hacker

  52. Pingback: cut the rope cheats cosmic box

  53. Pingback: shisha pen tabak

  54. Pingback: ipad accessories on sale

  55. Pingback: lon rosen magic johnson agent

  56. Pingback: shorts for women

  57. Pingback: how to block porn sites

  58. Pingback: buy diploma

  59. Pingback: american academy of performing arts

  60. Pingback: Claremont search engine optimization services

  61. Pingback: Bee Removal Specialists

  62. Pingback: cheap hair extensions

  63. Pingback: vicidial server

  64. Pingback: Географ глобус пропил 2013 смотреть онлайн полный фильм цЯя

  65. Pingback: Gary Pryor Cuisine Capital

  66. Pingback: pure garcinia cambogia reviews

  67. Pingback: is wordpress best for seo

  68. Pingback: Read Full Report

  69. Pingback: jadwal bola hari ini

  70. Pingback: Adrian Morrison books

  71. Pingback: Anonymous

  72. Pingback: andrew ling phoenix

  73. Pingback: Невероятная жизнь Уолтера Митти фильм трейлер ёСЦ

  74. Pingback: free online web directories

  75. Pingback: How To Get Your Ex Boyfriend Back - Text The Romance Back System

  76. Pingback: sport apparel

  77. Pingback: belstaff jackets ebay

  78. Pingback: Finn ut mer

  79. Pingback: ecig

  80. Pingback: wikipedia

  81. Pingback: pemex english library

  82. Pingback: stain cleaning tips

  83. Pingback: empire

  84. Pingback: empire medical training reviews

  85. Pingback: dr. paul drago

  86. Pingback: source article

  87. Pingback: two poor teachers reviews

  88. Pingback:

  89. Pingback:

  90. Pingback: SWAG

  91. Pingback: event venue space

  92. Pingback: physical activity guidelines

  93. Pingback: horst ferrero

  94. Pingback: paul bunton

  95. Pingback: norwalk village dental center

  96. Pingback:

  97. Pingback:

  98. Pingback: jason

  99. Pingback: Ladera Lending Complaints

  100. Pingback:

  101. Pingback:

  102. Pingback: Dating Tester

  103. Pingback: tapout simpsons cheats

  104. Pingback: mary morrissey article

  105. Pingback: Anabolic Cooking Plan

  106. Pingback: รับทำ SEO ราคาถูก

  107. Pingback: degrees that get you jobs

  108. Pingback: naples dog walker

  109. Pingback: Jasa SEO

  110. Pingback: tv izle

  111. Pingback: เสื้อผ้าแฟชั่นราคาถูก

  112. Pingback: dog poop

  113. Pingback: potty training tips

  114. Pingback: mountain bike racing

  115. Pingback: how to eliminate cellulite

  116. Pingback: Unlocked iPhone 5s

  117. Pingback: Search Engine Optimization

  118. Pingback: lon rosen facebook

  119. Pingback: travel and tourism career path

  120. Pingback: online casino

  121. Pingback: รับทำ SEO ราคาถูก

  122. Pingback: barang promosi

  123. Pingback: additional info

  124. Pingback: mary morrissey site

  125. Pingback: Timbangan Digital

  126. Pingback: เสื้อผ้าเด็ก

  127. Pingback: Deca Durabolin

  128. Pingback: buy essay for cheap

  129. Pingback: how to get rid of cellulite naturally

  130. Pingback: Bail Bond

  131. Pingback: youtube gaming partners

  132. Pingback: buy free essay

  133. Pingback:

  134. Pingback: Låna pengar

  135. Pingback: Free Sugar Daddy Dating Site

  136. Pingback: Pengrajin Drumband

  137. Pingback: smyga en titt på den här webbplatsen

  138. Pingback: Timbangan

  139. Pingback: smyga en titt på denna webbplats

  140. Pingback: NaziLLi.GolgeSiz.NeT

  141. Pingback: ยาผู้ชาย

  142. Pingback: reports stream

  143. Pingback: hill climb racing hack

  144. Pingback: buy essay for college

  145. Pingback: enviromental

  146. Pingback: payday loans

  147. Pingback: cialis

  148. Pingback: buy an essay paper

  149. Pingback: plantas purificadoras de agua

  150. Pingback: bail bonds costa covina

  151. Pingback: dog poop bags

  152. Pingback: hcgdiet direct

  153. Pingback: activedutygear

  154. Pingback: Orgasm

  155. Pingback: Orlando

  156. Pingback: Bee Removal SpeCialists

  157. Pingback: Oil and Gas Commissioning

  158. Pingback: dog poop bags

  159. Pingback: lytte til denne podcasten

  160. Pingback: Coupons Dallas

  161. Pingback: breaking bad season 2

  162. Pingback: everest trekking

  163. Pingback: woodworking projects and plans

  164. Pingback: Best graphic design templates and photoshop psd for free download

  165. Pingback: dog waste bags

  166. Pingback: we buy cars

  167. Pingback: Internetseite mit Doppelkopfregeln

  168. Pingback: How to Get Your Ex Back in 2 Weeks

  169. Pingback: buffalo web design

  170. Pingback: weight loss pills with ephedra

  171. Pingback: lakeville tenure

  172. Pingback: Free XBOX Live codes today only

  173. Pingback: scamwarners

  174. Pingback: Escort site seo

  175. Pingback: günlük burç yorumlari

  176. Pingback: สบู่กลูต้าน้ำนมข้าว

  177. Pingback: weight loss pills

  178. Pingback: david sills statistics

  179. Pingback: url

  180. Pingback: wholesale warranty

  181. Pingback: Unlock iPhone Turkey

  182. Pingback: iherb coupon code

  183. Pingback: megasesso

  184. Pingback: online blackjack

  185. Pingback: coupon

  186. Pingback: business telephone systems

  187. Pingback: รับทำ SEO ราคาถูก

  188. Pingback: Jual Timbangan Digital

  189. Pingback: viagra

  190. Pingback: Sliding Driveway Gates Deals and Discounts

  191. Pingback: Data logger temperatures

  192. Pingback: funny Pictures

  193. Pingback: tube8

  194. Pingback: paket pulau tidung

  195. Pingback: fontanny

  196. Pingback: contact

  197. Pingback: prom dresses plus size cheap

  198. Pingback: job

  199. Pingback: asuransi jiwa prudential

  200. Pingback: Sex Crime Minor Richmond Virginia

  201. Pingback: best mobile games

  202. Pingback: Porno Hub

  203. Pingback: click here

  204. Pingback: dog sitters naples florida

  205. Pingback: payday loans

  206. Pingback: Trackback

  207. Pingback: hcg

  208. Pingback: Porn Hub

  209. Pingback:

  210. Pingback: body shop irvine

  211. Pingback: Crowdfunding, Conference

  212. Pingback: Jelly Gamat

  213. Pingback: big truck

  214. Pingback: article source

  215. Pingback: points playstation gratuit

  216. Pingback: live online dating

  217. Pingback: Play Free Dress Up Games

  218. Pingback: torrent

  219. Pingback: part time jobs in singapore

  220. Pingback: iphone 6

  221. Pingback: smyga en titt på den här webbplatsen

  222. Pingback: floor installation london

  223. Pingback: obat kanker

  224. Pingback: mini quad hire swindon

  225. Pingback: Reiki London Glastonbury

  226. Pingback: hotel di Jakarta

  227. Pingback: World Map

  228. Pingback: Pulau Tidung

  229. Pingback: castle bounce houses

  230. Pingback: laser spine surgery

  231. Pingback: goa india travel

  232. Pingback: more here

  233. Pingback: vimax

  234. Pingback: Sunglasses

  235. Pingback: overnight pet sitter in naples

  236. Pingback: pet sitting in naples

  237. Pingback: Selena Gomez

  238. Pingback: temp street

  239. Pingback: Fair Oaks

  240. Pingback: mens clothing

  241. Pingback: recommended by moms

  242. Pingback:

  243. Pingback: Read More Here

  244. Pingback: recette de crepe

  245. Pingback: how to make beats

  246. Pingback: kaos murah bandung

  247. Pingback: see this

  248. Pingback: website

  249. Pingback: blog

  250. Pingback: read here

  251. Pingback: pet dog food supply product care

  252. Pingback: custom id badge

  253. Pingback: smyga en titt här

  254. Pingback: social networking marketing

  255. Pingback: LCD Display

  256. Pingback: Perry Belcher profile

  257. Pingback: omega-3 natures answer

  258. Pingback: DWI Attorney Houston

  259. Pingback: sell gold Orlando

  260. Pingback: how to make money on instagram

  261. Pingback: window tinting west palm beach

  262. Pingback: lida

  263. Pingback: Love Letters For Him

  264. Pingback: huse iphone 4s

  265. Pingback: Another Title

  266. Pingback: nails scottsdale

  267. Pingback: imajhosting

  268. Pingback: Twitter+ mainee..bo54

  269. Pingback: breast actives cream

  270. Pingback: stamp duty calculator victoria

  271. Pingback: swimming pool fill in

  272. Pingback: swimming pool removal

  273. Pingback: Michigan real estate investors

  274. Pingback: mp3 volume booster

  275. Pingback: girls in yoga shorts

  276. Pingback: child porn

  277. Pingback: Sosyal iliskiler

  278. Pingback: Hop Over To This Site

  279. Pingback: Excelerol reveiw

  280. Pingback: Shaahin Cheyene

  281. Pingback: казино

  282. Pingback: perceraian

  283. Pingback: mp3gain alternative

  284. Pingback: rug cleaning service

  285. Pingback: prada store

  286. Pingback: visit this

  287. Pingback: bat world case

  288. Pingback: Facebook

  289. Pingback: in home pet sitter

  290. Pingback: click here

  291. Pingback: hydrocodone

  292. Pingback: embroidery designs download

  293. Pingback: baton rouge roofing company

  294. Pingback: Generic Levitra

  295. Pingback: irvine auto repair

  296. Pingback: prada bags

  297. Pingback: онлайн казино

  298. Pingback: Best MBA colleges bangalore

  299. Pingback: Rancho Santa Fe

  300. Pingback: hacker un compte facebook

  301. Pingback: casino

  302. Pingback: casino online

  303. Pingback: Perry Belcher Vimeo

  304. Pingback: Trackback

  305. Pingback: ipad repair leeds

  306. Pingback: computer repair for all brand

  307. Pingback: 87 harrogate road

  308. Pingback: option binaire trading

  309. Pingback: Melanotan ii

  310. Pingback: option binaire le monde

  311. Pingback: ipad screen repair leeds

  312. Pingback: mural printing

  313. Pingback: boat radio installation

  314. Pingback: camernews

  315. Pingback: PMP Certification)

  316. Pingback: Collar light

  317. Pingback: Free Parking Games

  318. Pingback: xbox live gold free

  319. Pingback: Links